Monday, August 31, 2009

One checking account does not waive recordkeeping requirements.


In the comments to
Indies are not Corporations Monica, who is an attorney, wants to know “how to avoid commingling if the funds are in the same account.”

Your choice is not between commingling or not being able to keep accurate, provable records. If an indie has one checking account and, let’s say, uses Quicken for her recordkeeping then she might do the following:

** A meal with a client would be categorized as M&E for business meals and entertainment. Lunch with her daughter would be categorized as Family Dining.

** Expenses at the printers might be categorized as Photocopies-Printing or Family Wedding Invitations.

** For money in she might categorize the $1,000 as Graphic Design Income:Clyde Client. Whereas the $100 from mom would be categorized as Personal Inflow:Birthday Gift.

If the above transactions were questioned in an audit the indie would need to show the back-up for the business expense and income transactions as well as proof that the $100 was a gift from mom and not a payment from a client.

A Quicken report shows business income and expenses in a format acceptable to the IRS. And because of the ease of one account the records would likely be more accurate than flipping money back and forth from one account to another as funds ebb and flow but not necessarily as needed. Self-employeds do not find it easy to annotate account transfers accurately and so transfers often end up looking like income.

For the same reason, I advise independent professionals to not spilt checks. A $1,000 payment from a client should be deposited as a $1,000 payment. If $200 cash is needed then write yourself a check for $200 cash. It makes the audit-trail less wiggly.

Of course, the above applies to sole proprietorships and those sole proprietorships not operating as an LLC – unless the LLC is for show only.

Note that for a one-person business, even if that one-person business were a corporation, in an audit the IRS would want to see statements from all personal bank accounts as well as the accounts of the corporation. The one-person business would be required to prove the source of all the deposits into the personal accounts.

-- June Walker

Sunday, August 30, 2009

Stupid questions are those unasked.

Hi June:

This is probably a stupid question, but does the accountant that does my taxes need to be in the same state?

Thanks!
Carrie


Hi Carrie,

I'm sure you've heard that the only stupid question is the one unasked.


No, your tax pro does not have to be in the same state as you. Just be sure she knows about your state's taxes.

Best,
June

Monday, August 24, 2009

Indies are not Corporations

The header on my blog says, “June Walker, Tax and Financial Advisor to the self-employed.” On my website, blog, and in my books I say:


“Whether you call yourself a
1099 Worker
Sole Proprietor
Freelancer
Subcontractor
Free Agent
or
Self-employed
you are an independent professional.
The IRS classifies you as an independent contractor.
I call you an indie.”


Well, I know all you indies are smart enough to know that I am talking to you, advising you, teaching you. I am not addressing my advice to corporations. Pretty straightforward, one might think.

Many of you also know that my 30-years’ experience has shown me that most attorneys blatantly advise indies to incorporate for no good reason. And that incorporation often makes an indie’s life unnecessarily complicated and costs money in corporation set-up fees and tax preparation fees.

Also pretty straightforward, one might think.

In my post, You Do Not Need A Business Checking Account I advise indies, both as clients and as readers, that it isn’t necessary to have a separate business checking account – that it’s simpler, easier, and because of the nature of an indie venture, it works better just using a personal checking account for both personal and business needs.

I have examined some of the reaction to that post in
There’s no shortage of bad advice out there.

Much of the reaction, especially from lawyers, has been hot-air-ballooned into warnings about how the only safe business structure for indies is incorporation. We can talk more about that at a later date.

For now I want to address something else. As you, my indie readers know, I pressure you to present your questions carefully. Whether you’re a massage therapist, sculptor, IT consultant, psychologist, carpenter, writer, cruise ship entertainer, furniture refinisher, or astrologer when asking a question you will get an accurate, appropriate answer only if you provide the right information. Sometimes I’m pretty harsh about that. That’s because words mean something and accuracy is important. If careless with words not only will you likely get a wrong answer but carelessness with words makes for sloppy thinking.

That said, I can’t let Attila Attorney respond to my posts by being inaccurate in his quotes of what I said.

In
his post here, Attila Attorney, Esq. wrote, and this is a direct, accurate quote:

“I recently wrote in a post titled
Tax Advice, Legal Advice & Piercing the Corporate Veil that it would be legal malpractice for an attorney to advise his corporate and business clients to commingle their personal and business funds.

“I wrote the post in response to June Walker who had written a blog post titled
You Do Not Need a Business Checking Account in which she proceeded to give that very advice to her clients and readers.”

The problem with Attila’s premise: My readers are indies, not corporations. None of my clients is a corporation unless I am in the process of dissolving the corporation for him or her. I never mentioned corporations in that post. And, with 30 years of accounting experience [He’d know that because my blog header says “since 1979”] I’d be pretty silly were I to say that corporations don’t need to keep completely separate business and personal records. That’s one of the reasons I advise my wedding photographer clients not to incorporate. Just ask Billy Bridesnapper. He’ll tell you.

Attila continued: “Ms. Walker responded with a post titled
There’s No Shortage of Bad Advice Out There. In it, she reiterated her advice to commingle, corrected my grammar and called me ‘Atilla the lawyer.’”

No, Mr. Attorney, I did not advise "to commingle funds.” I said a business checking account was not needed for indies. Big difference.

This is similar to the faulty logic of many accountants and attorneys who tell indies you must have a profit in 3 out of 5 years in order to be a business. No way. The IRS says that if you have a profit in 3 out of 5 years you are a business. Think of it this way: If it’s your birthday you will get a gift does not mean that if you receive a gift it must be your birthday.

And one more thing about Attila. In his attempt at quoting me he said I called him “Atilla the lawyer.” The gods invented quotation marks to mean that the words in between them are exactly what the person said.
What I said exactly is: “Attila Attorney.”

In my book Lily Legal wants to know if, because she writes her briefs at the dining room table, she can deduct the dining room as a home office. [She can not because she also has dinner parties there.] Maybe in my next book Lax Lawyer will be asking if his reading glasses are a business deduction because he keeps misreading quotes. [He can deduct them if he uses them only for business and has another pair for reading the funnies.]

Accuracy is important. Not just for indies, but equally for accountants and attorneys.

I have received many emails from indies and tax professionals. All the indies say how much easier it is to keep accurate records using one checking account. Most of the tax pros say it's wrong. One pro said I was engaging in "chick think." Wow! More about that some other time.

Please do read The Tax Lawyer’s Blog and the comments. You need to know the kind of advice that is out there so that you can make the right choices in choosing a tax or legal professional.

June Walker

Sunday, August 23, 2009

Bravo Indies!

Oh, thank you indies! I am so pleased to know that you read my info and use it in your professional life. Congratulations. It does my indie-accountant heart good.

Here are a few of the emails that I received about You Do Not Need A Business Checking Account and There’s no shortage of bad advice out there.. More to come, as well as my next reponse to Attila Attorney.

To recap what I've said here, there and everywhere:

1. The IRS does not require a sole proprietorship to have a separate business checking account. Of course records must show whether inflow and outgo are for business or personal, however, for indies that is typically more easily and more accurately accomplished with one checking account.

2. Corporations must keep separate records for business and personal. For independent professionals that's one of the negatives of incorporation.

3. LLC law is governed by each state. If you formed an LLC for the purpose of liability protection you need to check whether your state requires separate accounts for business and personal in order to maintain that protection. If in doubt, keep them apart.


From Lisa Lepine, Consultant, Branding for Creatives
Portland, OR
I love your eletter re: one checking acct. Don't let those dissenters get you down!

For many freelancers - having separate checking accounts is just ridiculous.I tried it for about a month - and still have a stack of checks that I will never use. I have followed your approach for the last few years with confidence and peace of mind.What makes your advice so dependable is that you truly LOOK AT THINGS THROUGH THE LENS OF TRULY SMALL BUSINESS. Here is a gadget some folks would love. -- Neat Receipts.


From NancyKay Sullivan Wessman, WessComm, LLC
Jackson, Mississippi
Thanks for the advice!
I do have a business account, but it’s in my Federal Credit Union; so it’s basically free. My desire was to NEED to keep work and personal money separate – but, sigh, I’ve never had enough of either to justify. Still, the business checks come in handy for buying some things. Most of the time, everything that can gets charged for easy access to American Express and Visa end-of-year statements. That makes identifying the business vs personal expenses fairly easy. . .

I especially like getting advice from another woman and, specifically, one who lives in Santa Fe near my friends. Bill and Sue and Margaret!

Best to you!


From Rose at Content Matters LLC in Colorado Springs, CO
Writing, Training, and Project Services for people who need help with the content that matters to them.Rose.CMLLC@gmail.comhttp://www.content-matters.com/
Dear June -


I'm a sole proprietor LLC with a service business and in-home office. I read your post and the two contrarian posts, and I have several responses based on my 15 years as an Indie.

Either the contrarians have not read your book or have forgotten key points that you make in it, such as that an Indie needs to find the system that works best for her. In no way are you insisting that people use only one account.

It is only in the past several years that I began using two accounts. The primary factor influencing my switch was the increased frequency of business income and expenses due to an increase in clients. To use an analogy, it was ok to put all my socks and stockings in the same drawer so long as I could keep the drawer neat. When I started spending more time sorting socks than wearing them, it was time to use two drawers: one for socks and one for stockings.

I keep track of all my personal and business monies in a single Quicken file, which lets me see at a glance the balance of any account and whether I need to make any transfers. I tried using two files, one for personal and one for business, and abandoned that in a hurry because I had to track inflow-outflow via paper reports. This is another example of not making your system any harder than it has to be.

I reconcile all monies at least once a month; I tried doing it less frequently and didn't like it.

A business associate is a Sub-S with a business that is far more complicated than mine. She reconciles just once, at the end of the year. Different strokes for different folks (cliche but true). We each trust our systems to work for us.

Over the years your book and your site have helped tremendously in getting myself "straight" about how to best manage my checking accounts, credit cards, and records as an Indie. You are doing a great job and a great service by focusing on the Indie as you do!


Thank you, all.
June Walker

Thursday, August 20, 2009

You don't have to be a math whiz to figure out estimated taxes.


Hi June,

My name is Pete, from Boston, MA. For the past few months I've been freelancing as a web designer.

I've had a hard time finding the right information on estimated taxes. Basically, I've been just about scared away from continuing my freelance business and feel like cutting my losses, wiping my hands of this and finding a job that will give me a W-2.

The bottom line is: I've made about $10,000 total since I started freelancing in May, and I know I need to make a payment by September 15th. But I simply do not know how to figure out what amount I should be paying - even though I've researched endlessly (as you may have guessed - I'm not a math whiz). All the information out there on the web and in books seems to direct me to last year's taxes - 'take your adjusted gross income from last year, and...' - but I don't see how that's relevant at all when I just started doing this in May (also, I was a student most of last year).

Also, I can't figure out if my wife's income (she's a public school teacher) should come into play when estimating my tax payment.

I've spoken with a couple of accountants through personal contacts of mine, but I haven't gotten far on free advice. I've wondered if I need to just pull the trigger and hire an accountant to help me. I hope you can give some advice.

I found your site through searching 'can I pay estimated tax with a credit card', so you can imagine I'm sweating this quite a bit right now :)

Thanks very much for your time.

- Pete

PS - Even a quick answer like "You made $10,000, your estimated tax is $4,000" would be fantastic.


Oh my goodness, Pete. Stop sweating. First of all, nothing horrendous happens if you don't pay estimated taxes on time or ever. You may pay what you owe later on. And, you may owe some penalty and interest. Maybe.

Husband and wife typically file a joint return. Calculations are based on their combined income and expenses. Their total tax is based on their total income and various deductions.

If there is money coming in on which tax was not withheld -- for instance, dividends from investments [OK bad example at this time] let's say rental income from the beach house, well then estimated taxes may be necessary.

Or there may be large amounts of income on which no tax was withheld but perhaps there was over-withholding on wages that made up for it so no estimateds are required.

To determine estimated taxes you need to look at your entire tax situation.

That said, here's an example with real numbers. Plan on paying about 1/3 of your net income toward taxes. Could be more. Could be less. But that's a safe bet.

So if you had $10,000 gross income and only $1000 expenses against it then your net is $9000. So plan on $3000 to the feds and state government.

Or: $10,000 gross, minus $4000 expenses, leaves $6000 net. So only $2000 goes to taxes.

You said you're not a math whiz. If you had six bottles of beer and two friends and you wanted to share, how many bottles would each get? That's 6 divided by 3 = 2. Now add the zeros.

Here are two must read posts: Estimated Taxes and Estimated Tax: How much should I pay?

Do let me know if this doesn't help you with the sweats.

Cheers,
June

Recent Grads Need Help With Taxes and Recordkeeping

This is from Jess and came as a comment to my post Designers Dozen: Tax Saving Tips for the Graphic Artist . Since it is typical of questions I receive from recent graduates I decided to give it more attention.

Graphic design students head out upon graduation, most of them toward freelancing, without a clue about how to handle income and expenses.

From Jess ... Thanks for this great article. I graduated from a graphic design school 3 weeks ago and have just started working full time as a graphic designer.

I have the receipts from the expenses during school, my mac, books, the course itself and going along to design based events. Can I claim any of these items? I use the same mac bought at school in my current position and I look at the books I have? I was also wondering if you knew about phones and phone bills if used for business?

THANKS HEAPS for your time! It is wonderful being able to access this information.
Jess



Congratulations, Jess, on both graduation and the work you got.

If you were not working or actively seeking work while in school you cannot deduct as business expenses any of the costs you incurred.

You can, however, deduct assets. In your case, assets are things -- computer, books, any kind of equipment. Your cost-basis for deducting these things -- in other words, the amount considered your business expense -- is not what you paid for them but their fair-market-value on the day you started your business. That means the day you started looking for work.

For instance, the fair-market-value of your Mac would be what some other graphic designer would pay you for it on that day.

The same with your books. Think of it as: On the day you tossed your cap in the air and said you were ready for clients, what would an incoming freshman pay you for your books? That amount is the fair-market-value of the books and your basis for deduction.


Hope that helps.

And thanks. Happy that my is helpful.

-- June

Monday, August 17, 2009

There’s no shortage of bad advice out there.

Indies, an alert: Be careful. Know your source.

Sammy Segar, CPA, is the composite figure I use in my writings to depict the tax pro who totally misunderstands indie life; my recent blogpost,
You Do Not Need A Business Checking Account, woke the real Sammy Segars out of their after-lunch naps.

Last Friday
The Wandering Tax Pro, Robert D. Flach took respectful disagreement with my post in his You Do Need A Business Checking Account.

Flach advocates a separate business checking account because an indie should “do as much as possible to give your self-employment activity the appearance of a real business entity so that the IRS does not come back and say that it is really a ‘hobby.’” But then he steps on his own message by citing the chronic problem of indies with business checking accounts – what to do when the money gets low. Well, he says, “loan” money to the business account from your personal account and then return it later. If you have attended my seminars or read
my book you know: That leaves a very wiggly audit trail for the IRS to follow.

He quotes my observation that in an IRS publication “you are urged to open a business checking account.” But he fails to include the rest of the comment, which was my main point: “The very next example from the IRS in the publication is the mixed use – personal and business – of your automobile. So, let’s see how efficient two checking accounts would be in this situation – hmm … guess you are expected to pay for each gas purchase with two checks – one for the personal use amount of gas and a business check for the business use portion.”

Flach says: “a separate business checking account is not a strict requirement.” I am not sure how a “strict requirement” differs from a plain requirement but the IRS didn’t require – it “urged,” which is no requirement at all.

Mr. Flach’s website does indicate that he works with self-employeds. He offers information to the “sole proprietor and one-man LLC.“ Well, if we were still in the 20th century I could understand, but this is the 21st. One-man!

Another response to my post came from
The Tax Lawyer's Blog . Let’s call him Attila Attorney.“ In a recent post,” he writes in astonishment, “she advises her business clients to commingle their business funds with their personal funds. You read that write. She advises the commingling of funds.” Yes, indies, you read that right. He did say “write.”

Then he warns: In advising that an indie doesn’t need a separate checking account I am “engaging in the unlicensed practice of law and it’s dangerous.” I’m not sure if he means dangerous to me or to you indies. I didn’t realize that advising against setting up a business checking account was fraught with such peril.

Oh -- and I was not going to mention this but I just had to. He says: “First, Ms Walker may be the most brilliant, competent, well-meaning person on the face of the planet …” Well, my mother and my husband always thought so and I’m pleased to know that A. Attorney, Esq., is considering the possibility.

He follows that with, “Second, and more importantly (his seventh grade teacher would have corrected that to “important”), Ms. Walker is giving business owners horribly bad advice.” (Oh, wait. Maybe I shouldn't correct his grammar because I'm not a licensed teacher.)

He has warned of danger and spoken of horror. But should we be getting goose-bumps and feeling our hair standing on end? Not really, because there is nothing illegal, immoral, fattening or unwise for a sole proprietor, who is not an LLC, to conduct business by depositing income or paying for business expenses from a personal checking account. For that matter, for reasons explained on my website and blog, it’s smart.

Attila Attorney then abruptly changes the subject to the protections that await the indie who does exactly what the lawyers want him to do – form a corporation.

He warns indies – likely in his thinking they are all corporate monarchs -- against “a general commingling of corporate activity and/or funds and those of the person or persons who control the corporation.” Well, duh! That would be a serious mistake.


But can Attila keep his attention span focused long enough to note that my blogpost never mentioned corporations? Did I advise: Don’t set up a separate checking account, even if you form a corporation? Of course not. Whatever his motive for changing the subject, it gives him a chance to plug incorporation – a legal step near and dear to the hearts of many lawyers.

And when Jeff Day, an enrolled agent, in a comment to the post disagrees with Attila the Tax Lawyer, Attila responds to Jeff with: “If you have a serious business, it’s unwise to operate as a sole proprietorship and probably malpractice for a lawyer not to point that out to his clients.”

I’m trying to think of a word that properly describes his assertion that advising against a business checking account is practicing law without a license or not advising to incorporate is “malpractice.” “Preposterous” somehow doesn’t seem strong enough.

Of course, the issue we should be looking at today isn’t practicing law without a license or malpractice or man-only businesses. It’s Attila and Sammy giving tax and legal advice to self-employed independent professionals without really understanding how indie businesses function.

June Walker